[8] He and Wyse were part of a heel stable with The Bad Crew known as The Pack which dominated Hardway Wrestling among several other Northeastern independent promotions during the late 1990s and early 2000s before their falling out initiated a major and long-running feud between the two teams.
He failed to regain the title in a three-way match with newly crowned WXW Heavyweight Champion Jak Molsonn and Oxx Hogg (substituting for Jack Daniels) on September 30.
After a nearly five-month reign, he and Flash also lost the tag titles when Bad Crew #2 defeated The Hungarian Barbarian in another singles match in Northampton, Pennsylvania on November 12, 1999.
Later that year, he also lost to WXW Heavyweight Champion "Wildman" Salvatore Bellomo in a three-way match with Sugaa in Hazleton on September 16.
The next month, he appeared at an October 25 show for Atomic Championship Wrestling in Adamstown, Pennsylvania with Nick Berk, The Backseat Boyz, Rockin' Rebel, Van Hammer and ECW stars Little Guido and Tony DeVito.
On November 1, he also faced Dino Divine in a steel cage match in Palo Alto, Pennsylvania[13] and, a week later, lost the HW Heavyweight title to Mongoose in Northampton.
[15] In January 2003, Bad Crew Paul gave up the title after winning it from Crazy Jake in Castle Hill, Pennsylvania earlier that month.
[18] He and Wyse were also featured in the NCW Hottie's & Bodies calendar which included Danny Rose, Adam Flash, Mike Quackenbush, Greg Matthews, Tom Brandi and King Kong Bundy.
On April 19, 2008, he and Wyse faced the United Kingdom's Andrew Bates on the first night of NCW's Ballroom Blitz tour in a no disqualification match with his manager The Chippendale Judge at the Tourist Inn in Hallam, Pennsylvania.
[22] The following year, he and Wyse announced their retirement and wrestled their last match together, along with Paul "Fat Paulie" Olesak, Jr., at a special NCW show entitled Final Night in Boots at the York County School of Technology.