New York Rangers pre and post-game radio host Don La Greca and WWE Network and Hot 97 radio host Peter Rosenberg were former co-hosts until 2024.

On his radio show, Kay delves into a variety of topics related to current sports, especially those notable in the New York area.

Kay also touches on non-sports topics in popular culture and public controversy on occasion.

The final episode of that iteration of "The Michael Kay Show" aired on December 13, 2024.

On January 6, 2025, the new version of the show from 1-3 pm, with Michael Kay only, began airing.