[4] Elmer Fudd, portraying the mischievous god Cupid, delights in shooting arrows at male animals to make them fall in love with the nearest female, regardless of species.

Elmer's antics continue as he tries to shoot Daffy, but he complains that he is now henpecked due to being forced into marriage and becoming the father of many ducklings, including a two-headed one, the last time he was shot.

Undeterred, Elmer seeks revenge by shooting a giant arrow at Daffy, causing further chaos and misunderstandings involving a hen and her rooster husband.

When The Stupid Cupid was reissued, a "Blue Ribbon" title card was added to the opening sequence, and an ending scene is believed to have been removed.

As usual, Tashlin approaches his cartoon as a cinematic tableau in which wildly distorted characters experience exaggerated emotions...