[9] In June 2020, Muddy Knees Media and The Totally Football Show became part of The Athletic.

[12] The Totally Football Show: American Edition was launched in October 2018 hosted by US soccer record caps holder Cobi Jones.

The Monday and Thursday editions of the show typically focus on news around the English Premier League.

The Tuesday edition of the show, known as the "European edition," usually focuses on Serie A, La Liga, the German Bundesliga and Ligue 1, as well as the UEFA Champions League and any other European leagues making news the previous weekend, with Richardson regularly joined by contributors James Horncastle, Raphael Honigstein, Julien Laurens and Alvaro Romeo.

[19] In February 2023 the show was nominated in the Podcast category at the British Sports Journalism Awards.