The Wolverines won their first Thunder Bay Junior B Hockey League title in 2005–06 in only their third year of existence.

They started off the tourney against the North Winnipeg Satelites of the Keystone Junior Hockey League with a 6–4 loss.

The Wolverines then were blown out by the host Campbell River Storm of the Vancouver Island Junior Hockey League by a score of 8–2.

The Wolverines finished their season with an 8–3 blowout loss to the Delta Ice Hawks of the Pacific International Junior Hockey League.

They moved directly into the league final against the highly competitive Thunder Bay Northern Hawks.

The Wolverines, as Northern Ontario Jr. B champions, received their second crack at the Keystone Cup in Fort Qu'Appelle, Saskatchewan.

They started off the tournament on a promising note—their first point in three years: the Wolverines tied the Pilot Butte Storm 3–3.

Both the Wolverines and the Northern Hawks advanced to the Keystone Cup, played at the Thunder Bay Tournament Centre in April 2009.

The next day, they started by defeating the Pacific International Junior Hockey League's Richmond Sockeyes 3–1, then later beat the North Eastern Alberta Junior B Hockey League's Lloydminster Bandits 7–3 to clinch a spot in the tournament's gold medal game.

The Wolverines finished the tournament round robin with a perfect 5–0 record by defeating the Prairie Junior Hockey League's Saskatoon Royals 3–0.

For owner Bill MacLaurin, this was the third time he had dropped ownership of a team in the SIJHL (first was the Featherman Hawks and second was the Schreiber Diesels).

This was after a second season was announced by the club, that the team would be moving to the Fort William First Nation Arena, and tryout dates were given.