In the first round of the playoffs, Tifton Blue Sox beat the Douglas Trojans 3 games to 2 and advanced.
William Barnes and Dave Coble served as managers, as Tifton failed to qualify for the league playoffs.
[9] Tifton joined the Albany Cardinals, Americus Rebels, Brunswick Pirates, Cordele A's, Moultrie To-baks, Valdosta Dodgers and Waycross Bears in beginning league play on April 25, 1951.
Tifton finished 3.0 games behind the first place Valdosta Dodgers, playing the season under managers Greek George, Edmond Dickerman and Parnell Ruark.
Tifton ended the 1953 regular season with a record of 84–55, placing third, as Edd Hartness served as manager.
[19] The Tifton Indians ended the 1954 Georgia-Florida League season with a record of 60–80, placing seventh and missing the playoffs, as Edd Hartness returned as manager.
The Indians finished 28.0 games behind the first place Brunswick Pirates in the final regular season standings.
The Blue Sox ended Georgia–Florida League regular season with a record of 59–80 and again finished 28.0 games behind the first place Brunswick Pirates.
[26] From 1949 to 1956, the Tifton Blue Sox, Indians and Phillies teams hosted minor league home games at Eve Park.