That deal expired on September 30, 2014, with the arena reverting to the Prescott Valley Event Center name.

The venue has hosted well-known bands such as Toby Keith, Cody Johnson, Miranda Lambert, Chicago, Godsmack, Breaking Benjamin, Three Doors Down, and ZZ Top.

The venue hosted a college basketball game on November 30, 2011, when Brigham Young University faced Northern Arizona.

The Wranglers would enlist the Findley Toyota Center as their home arena for games starting with their inaugural season in 2021.

After starting their inaugural season with an awful 1–13 record (winning their only game against the south side rivals in Tucson), the Wranglers would see a dramatic change in results the following season afterward, going 12–2 for a second place finish in their conference (behind the rivaling Rattlers) and then crushing the Duke City Gladiators before winning close matches against the rivaling Rattlers and Quad City Steamwheelers to become IFL champions in only their second season of existence.