[6] Coenraad was thrust into a starting role in the 2013–14 NBL season after the retirement of club legend Glen Saville.
[12] In the 2016–17 NBL season, Coenraad and the Hawks once again lost in the grand final series to the Perth Wildcats.
[13] Coenraad signed a two-year deal in 2018,[14] and in December 2019, he became the third player in Hawks history to reach 300 NBL games.
[15] After initially retiring in November 2020,[16] Coenraad returned to the Hawks in May 2021 to play out the 2020–21 NBL season as an injury replacement for Cameron Bairstow.
[17] Coenraad initially re-joined the Hawks for the 2021–22 NBL season as an injury replacement player[18] but was soon elevated to a fully contracted roster position.