[1][2] On January 13, 2018, the club won its first major title when it beat KR in the Icelandic Basketball Cup finals.

[3][4] On 30 September 2018, Tindastóll defeated KR in the Icelandic Super Cup, 103-72.

[5] On 18 May 2023, Tindastóll won its first national championship after defeating Valur 3-2 in a finals rematch from 2022.

[6] Note: Flags indicate national team eligibility at FIBA-sanctioned events.

Players may hold other non-FIBA nationalities not displayed.