They released three studio albums —Shed (2011), Floral Green (2012), and Hyperview (2015) — gradually shifting from a hardcore punk–oriented sound towards shoegaze and indie rock.

In 2005, the band added Shane Moran on second guitar and recorded two demos in 2005 and 2006, during which they played shows in what they call a "small, tight-knit community" around Kingston, Pennsylvania.

[3] During these years, Title Fight altered their sound to a more melodic hardcore–oriented style, with influences such as Jawbreaker, Seaweed, Lifetime, Knapsack, and the Promise Ring.

On February 23, SideOneDummy Records opened preorders for a new 7" titled "Flood of '72", the album's second single; it was released on April 12 and included an acoustic version of the song.

Title Fight announced via Tumblr in July 2012 that their next album, Floral Green, would come out on September 18,[14] and its lead single "Head in the Ceiling Fan", was released as a free download.

On October 19, 2012, Title Fight hosted a record release show in Warrior Run, Pennsylvania, along with the Menzingers, Tigers Jaw, Gypsy, and Grey Zine prior to headlining a US tour with supporting acts Tigers Jaw, Pianos Become the Teeth, Whirr, Young Beats, and Single Mothers.

Title Fight released the four-song EP Spring Songs on November 12, 2013, through Revelation Records,[18] with its second track, "Be a Toy", premiering on August 12 via SPIN.

[22] While headlining Outbreak Festival in the UK on April 29, 2017 – in what would end up being the band's second-to-last show before going inactive – vocalist Ned Russin said, "If this is it, it’s been a wild and beautiful ride.

"[23] The band's final show was a benefit concert for their friend Aaron Warman, held on January 26, 2018 at the Revolution Bar & Music Hall in Amityville, New York, with Turnstile opening.

[24][25] During the hiatus, Title Fight's social media accounts occasionally post updates with information regarding merchandise and the members' other projects.

Ned Russin also said about Title Fight's inactivity, "we've never said 'hiatus,' we've never said 'broken up,' ... 'the big breakup' is just something I do not care to be a part of, but it’s also something that doesn’t really exist anymore.

[33] The members of Title Fight are also known for their presence in many other Wilkes-Barre hardcore bands—most notably Bad Seed, which featured Shane on vocals and Jamie on bass.

Bad Seed released a demo in 2008 and a self-titled EP in 2009 on 6131 Records, and they played Sound and Fury and This Is Hardcore Fest before disbanding in 2010.