He then played for the Imperials (a forerunner of East Fremantle) in the West Australian Football Association (WAFA), and then for Carlton in the Victorian Football League (VFL).
[2] O'Day made his debut for the Carlton Football Club in Round 1 of the 1898 season.
He was only with Carlton for the single season, playing 13 games and kicking 8 goals.
The 8 goals he kicked made him the club's leading goal-kicker for that year -- the lowest leading goal tally in the club's history.
This Australian rules football biography of a person born in the 1870s is a stub.