Larry Flick from Billboard stated in his review that producer/songwriter Steve "Silk" Hurley "once again reaffirms his position as Chicago's finest on this wriggling, R&B-inflected houser", noting that newcomer Sims "exudes the confidence and range of a seasoned pro, while remixer Maurice Joshua drops another of his deep underground workouts.

[3] In 1995, Mark Roland from Melody Maker asked, "Which one of you can truly say that you didn't dance around your handbag in gay abandon to her faultless 1992 house hit, 'Too Blind to See It'?

"[4] In a retrospective review, Pop Rescue called the song "infectious", adding that "laden with those catchy italia-house pianos, and fast beats, her vocals cut through them perfectly as she sings about a love lost.

"[5] Richard Riccio from the St. Petersburg Times wrote, "Best of all is the perfect balance she walks between dance floor drama and overdone diva kitsch, especially on the incredible stomp anthem, 'Too Blind to See It'.

Due to its success in the UK, Sims performed it on the British music chart TV show Top of the Pops twice.