They have numerous teams competing in competitions run by the Central Coast Division of Country Rugby League, from U/7s through to First Grade.

Toukley reached their maiden first grade Grand Final in 2022 and won against the Erina Eagles 20-10, their first premiership since the club began in 1967.

The following year, Toukley finished at the top of the table,[2] then defeated Milson Island in a major-semi-final and Wyong in a Grand Final,[3] to claim the Second Division premiership.

Toukley responded in the last minute, "On the fourth tackle the ball went out the backline until lock and captain Mark Burns had to regather a sloppy pass.

The Hawks led early and again late in the second half, prior to a penalty goal by opponents Budgewoi taking the score to 14-all at full time.

[11] Budgewoi players and supporters must have derived both satisfaction and relief when they defeated Toukley in the minor semi-final of 2001, ending the Hawk's season.

Losing the major semi-final to defending premiers Central Wyong (10–20), Toukley recovered with a win over Gosford Cougars, 38–14, to set-up a rematch.

[13] The club has fielded a team in many of the senior-level competitions since, and reached three lower grade grand finals: Under 17s and the inaugural Open Age league in 2010 and Under 18/1s in 2012.

Jack Cogger Adam Keighran Daniel Saifiti Jacob Saifiti Team numbers obtained and compiled from competition tables and match results published in the newspapers, Central Coast Express, Wyong Shire Advocate and Central Coast Express Advocate.

Numbers for 2003 and 2011 taken from copies of the Central Coast Division Junior Rugby League Yearbook of those years, supplied by Toukley Hawks RLFC.