[1] The team is represented in the Frontier League Hall of Fame by pitcher Scott Dunn and first baseman Chase Burch.

Brian Tollberg of the Chillicothe Paints was the first league alumnus to make the majors, beating Burkhart by a week in the 2000 season.

[7][8] The team repeated as Frontier League champions in 2002, again upsetting the league-best Washington Wild Things 3-1 in a best of five series for the title.

[17] The team then established consistency with players such 2012 Frontier League MVP Jose Vargas (.290 BA, 29 HR, 100 RBI) but lost in the division series in 2012 and 2013.

The Beach Bums added to the franchise championship history in 2015, advancing from a play-in game to take the title in a best of five series sweep, defeating the River City Rascals 3-0.

[22] The franchise's final Frontier League professional game was an 8-5 win over the Windy City ThunderBolts, played at Wuerfel Park on September 2, 2018, before 2,864 spectators.