The next season, they lost in the final of the 2012 Nova Scotia Men's Molson Provincial Championship to the Jamie Murphy rink.

Team found immediate success on the World Curling Tour, winning two events in 2015, the Bud Light Men's Cashspiel[4] and the Spitfire Arms Cash Spiel.

[8] At the 2017 Deloitte Tankard provincial championship, the rink finished the round robin with a 5–2 record, which put the team into the playoffs.

[11] Later that season, the team won the 2019 Deloitte Tankard in Dartmouth, Nova Scotia[12] qualifying them for the 2019 Tim Hortons Brier in Brandon, Manitoba for the first time.

[15] Colter formed his own rink in 2020 as a skip, but throwing third stones with teammates Robby McLean, Ian Juurlink and Cameron MacKenzie.

The pair represented Nova Scotia at the 2014 Canadian Mixed Doubles Curling Trials where they finished with a 1–6 record.