[4] To date, they have released four studio albums: Mend, Move On (2014), Chemical Miracle (2016), The American Dream (2018) and Suicide and Sunshine (2023).

[5] Everything Goes Away has five songs and it was written about a period of his life during which he lived in his high school town prior to moving to Newcastle.

[19] From 24 November to 17 December, the band embarked on their first US headlining tour with support from Free Throw, Grayscale, and Head North.

[22] In April 2019, Trophy Eyes performed as a support act for Bring Me the Horizon during the Australian leg of their First Love Tour alongside You Me At Six and Frank Carter & The Rattlesnakes.

Unlike their other songs, "Figure Eight" features the addition of a saxophone, which is rumoured to be played by bassist Jeremy Winchester.

[29] On 8 February 2023, long-time guitarist Andrew Hallett announced his departure from the band to focus on his family.

[33] On 12 April 2023, the band announced their fourth album Suicide and Sunshine, which was released on 23 June 2023 and features 15 tracks, including "Blue Eyed Boy" and "What Hurts the Most".

[34] During a 30 April 2024 show at Mohawk Place in Buffalo, New York, John Floreani blindly leaped into the crowd, landing on top of a woman who then suffered a broken neck, partially paralysing her.

The woman, Bird Piché, 24, is suing after she sustained spinal cord injuries, alleging negligence from the defendant, and their failure to prevent "unsafe and/or dangerous conditions."

The suit names the venue Mohawk Place, the promoter After Dark Entertainment, LLC, Trophy Eyes, and frontman John Floreani.