The company, which is headquartered in Conestoga, Pennsylvania, was a subsidiary of Kroger from 1985 until it was sold to private equity firm Peak Rock Capital in 2019.

In the early 2000s Turkey Hill's products were distributed in places further west, such as Buffalo, Pittsburgh, and Cleveland.

[10] In 2011, Turkey Hill partnered with PPL Renewable Energy and the Lancaster County Solid Waste Management Authority to purchase the electricity generated by two General Electric wind turbines on the Frey Farm landfill adjacent to the company's manufacturing facility.

The wind turbines are capable of producing enough power to supply 25 percent of the company's annual electricity demand.

[13] Turkey Hill Dairy has partnerships with the Snyder's of Hanover, Gertrude Hawk Chocolates, and Tootsie Roll Industries' Junior Mints, allowing the company to produce and distribute theme-flavored ice cream based on the products of these companies.

[21] The Turkey Hill Experience is a 17,000 sq ft (1,600 m2)[3] attraction based in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania that pays homage to Turkey Hill Dairy's history while highlighting its ice cream and iced tea-making processes.

[4] The Turkey Hill Experience includes a variety of interactive displays aimed at entertaining both children and adults.

The Turkey Hill Experience is located in a former Ashley and Bailey silk mill, part of which was originally built in 1899.