Tyler also carries a long history of athletic excellence in sports such as football, basketball, volleyball, and soccer.

[6] In September 23, 2009 a 16 year old student was held after a teacher and music therapist Todd Henry was fatally stabbed in their classroom.

The 1994 championship season featured the noteworthy 1994 John Tyler vs. Plano East high school football game, which ultimately won ESPN's 1995 Showstopper of the Year ESPY Award.

In the regional final against Plano East (played at Texas Stadium), John Tyler had a 41–17 lead with 2:42 remaining.

However, on the ensuing kickoff, John Tyler returner Roderick Dunn ran for a touchdown to win the game 48–44.