[4] They won the inaugural League1 Ontario League Cup defeating Sigma FC 2–1 in the final at BMO Field.

During the 2018 season, they played a friendly against Italian professional Serie A club Frosinone Calcio, losing by a score of 2–1, although Vaughan managed to take an early 1–0 lead in the match.

Following the 2018 season, Isacco left Vaughan to join the newly founded York9 FC as an assistant coach.

[15] They played HFX Wanderers FC of the Canadian Premier League in a two-legged series and hosted their home match at the Ontario Soccer Centre.

The two clubs drew 3–3 on aggregate but Vaughan failed to advance due to the away goals rule.