It has featured many prominent artists including Thursday, Hawthorne Heights, Silverstein, Taking Back Sunday, Bayside, Streetlight Manifesto, and A Day to Remember.

It was announced in April 2014 that the label would be sponsoring a Victory Records stage for the entirety of the Rockstar Energy Drink Mayhem Festival featuring five of their artists: Emmure, Ill Niño, Wretched, Islander and Erimha.

[8][9][10][11][12] Representing a catalog of over 5,000 songs, Another Victory has landed a multitude of big-name placements for its artists tracks various movies, games and advertisements including "Chain Gang" by Close Your Eyes in NHL 15,[13] "Like LaMotta" by Emmure on Secrets and Lies (U.S. TV series),[14] "All I Want" by A Day To Remember in Crazy Taxi: City Rush,[15] "Die Knowing" by Comeback Kid on The Challenge: Free Agents,[16][17] and "Let Me Teach You How To Eat" by The Reverend Horton Heat on Ridiculousness (TV series).

[23] In July 2012, it was announced that Victory would become the distribution home for Boston, MA based record label, We Are Triumphant.

The band also cited an incident involving the Victory Records marketing staff producing whoopie cushions for the promotion of their 2001 album Full Collapse, against their wishes.

"[44] In a 2021 podcast interview, Atreyu guitarist Dan Jacobs spoke ill of Victory and the label's founder, saying they had issues with "Tony Brummel and his awful, scummy ways".

[47] On July 12, 2015, Wil Francis of Horror Punk band Aiden posted on their official Facebook that they sold 500,000 albums total through Victory Records and were not paid.

"[51] Brummel allegedly issued public statements in the band's name criticizing hip-hop singer Ne-Yo (whose CD In My Own Words was Hawthorne Heights' most prominent competition on the Billboard 200 charts),[52] as well as urging fans and street team members to conceal copies of Ne-Yo's CD in record stores to sabotage his sales.

[53][54] In October 2006, a Chicago judge dismissed two of the three main claims in the band's suit, ruling that the trademark and copyright violation allegations were unfounded.

[58][59] On December 15, 2011, it was announced that metalcore band A Day to Remember planned on filing a civil action against the label for breach of contract.

[61] On October 5, 2013, news outlets reported that A Day to Remember had been given permission to self-release their new album Common Courtesy without any involvement from Victory.

We can honestly see why people give us negative feedback for one, the way we look and the fact that we got signed to a mainly hardcore metal label with just one song; we stick out like a sore thumb.

[69] On October 20, 2015, media outlets reported of a $1,000,000 lawsuit filed by Victory Records against lead vocalist Tomas Kalnoky.

As part of the settlement, Victory Records sold all Streetlight Manifesto master tapes back to the band.