The Cairo Egyptians, Clarksville Villagers, Henderson Hens, Hopkinsville Hoppers, Jackson Railroaders, Owensboro Distillers and Paducah Chiefs teams joined Vincennes in the newly formed league.
[7][8] The "Alices" nickname was later given to the Vincennes Lincoln High School teams, beginning in 1923 and continues today.
At the time the team folded the Alices had a 11–18 record, playing the season under managers Harry Chaney and Jack Tuite.
The Alices placed sixth in the Kentucky–Illinois–Tennessee League standings and compiled a record of 50–73, playing the season under managers Bill Popp and Luke Duffy.
The Paducah Indians won the league championship and finished 23.5 games ahead of last place Vincennes.
With permission from the National Association, the league halted play on August 17, 1905, due to the Yellow Fever epidemic.
Vincennes won the league championship with a record of 79–49, led by returning manager Eddie Kolb.
The Alices finished 9.0 games behind the second place Jacksonville Jacks in the final standings, as the league held no playoffs.
[1][15] Vincennes pitcher Hub Perdue led the league with 25 wins and 260 strikeouts and Phil Chenault had a 14-6 record.
The Alices joined the Charleston Evangelists, Danville Speakers, Linton Coal Miners, Mattoon Giants, Pana Coal Miners, Paris Parisians, Shelbyville Queen Citys, Staunton Speakers and Taylorville Tailors teams in league play [16] The Alices ended their 1908 season with a 47–48 record and in second place, playing the season under managers Harry Lloyd and Orville Wolfe.
Vincennes joined the Clarksville Volunteers, Harrisburg Merchants, Hopkinsville Hoppers, McLeansboro Miners and Paducah Indians teams in the reformed league.
Led by manager John Nairn, the Alices ended the season 7.5 games ahead of the second place Clarksville Volunteers team.
With a record of 34–92, the team placed eighth in the standings under managers Ollie Pickering, Bob Anderson, William McAndrews and John Nairn.