Primarily in the late Victorian Gothic architectural style, its complex massing and decoration include elements of other contemporary modes such as Romanesque Revival.

In front is a small lawn, sloping gently to the sidewalk, with a large mature tree and shrubbery on the side.

[1] The dark red painted brick exterior of the masjid is complemented by black asphalt roofing and rough-hewn bluestone courses.

Six stone steps and a railing lead to its ground-floor entrance, with paired batten doors in a Gothic opening with a similar treatment as the fellowship hall windows.

The third stage harbors the bell, with large arched louvered openings rising from another belt course, split by a third at the impost.

Above the corbeled roofline, the octagonal spire rises, topped by a cross and set off with four small pyramids at the corners, to 100 feet (30 m) high.

[1] At the worship space, a three-sided steeply pitched gabled section projects from the pyramid-roofed main block.

At the extreme west is a third entry, a projecting gabled vestibule with similar doors leading to a white wooden wheelchair ramp.

Oak slip pews, with scroll armrests and hymnal racks on the rear, are arranged in semicircular fashion around a dais and organ opposite.

[1] The plaster on sawn lath walls have beaded wainscoting, stained lighter than the chair rail at its top.

[1] The masjid's original layout followed Lewis Miller's Akron Plan, in which the Sunday school and worship areas were adjacent, with sliding partitions allowing for controlled access between the two.

[1] Another feature of the former that reflects the era of its construction is the auditorium-style worship space, in which the pews are arranged in a semicircle around the dais.

[1] The building's exterior is eclectic, another late 19th century touch, reflecting the move away from the early Gothic Revival's insistence on historically correct detail.

All reflected an era when Protestant church interiors were moving away from the asceticism that had characterized them earlier in the century, with the intent of providing an atmosphere more conducive to the proper spirit of worship.

A cornerstone-laying ceremony in August of that year featured the district's presiding elder and a 40-year member of the congregation, from the days when Walden United Methodist had just moved into the building being replaced.

It is two-and-a-half-story gabled Queen Anne Style home that has since been resided in vinyl and thus is not considered contributing to the National Register listing.

[1] At some point prior to the 1920s the partitions and fluid space of the Akron Plan interior were abandoned in favor of fixed walls.

[1] Later on in the 20th century, in the early 1960s, an engineering and construction campaign led to the excavation of a new basement and additional facilities below ground level.

[1] Maintenance costs for the building were still considerable enough that in 2007, members of the congregation voted narrowly to explore moving to a new site and constructing a new church.

[3] In November 2022, the building was purchased by Darul Quran WasSunnah, a non-profit Islam organization, and repurposed into a masjid.