The team last competed in the NCAA Division III and were members of the New Jersey Athletic Conference.
[4] Led by coach Josh S. Faulkner in their first season back, the Wildcats, as they were known at the time, finished the year with a 6–1 record.
[5] With a harder schedule the next year, the Wildcats compiled a 6–1 record again, only allowing two teams to score points against them.
[9] Copp stayed one year before being replaced by Al Brent, a former All-America Football Conference (AAFC) player.
Andrus played a significant role in turning Wesley from a junior college team to a four-year program, which he accomplished in 1986.
After Keating left the school, Mike Drass, an assistant since 1989, was promoted to the head coach position.
[13] At the time of his death, they had made the playoff tournament for 15 consecutive years, but were not able to win any championships.
In July 2020, it was announced that Delaware State University would acquire the college, ending the athletics program.
[20] Steve Colavito was the first; he spent a few years in the early 1970s with the team before transferring to Wake Forest.
[23] Joe Callahan, who was Division III's MVP in one year, was the first National Football League player to solely attend Wesley College.
Matt Gono is the only other Wesley attendee to play professionally; he was a member of the Atlanta Falcons and New York Giants.