By the 1890s, the members were ready for a newer building, and they contracted with master architect Samuel Hannaford to design it.

[3]: 3  Completed in 1896, the building was functionally unchanged for its first thirty years, although the first of multiple additions was constructed in 1926.

A clear example of the Gothic Revival style, the church is distinguished by a tall steeple crowned by a yet taller spire.

The overall massing of the building is composed by its multi-gabled form and extensive fenestration, filled with stained glass, and the exterior is covered with rough-faced ashlar stonework.

Much of the building's ornamentation is also placed on the steeple, including windows with fleurs de lis and quatrefoils in their designs, and buttresses supporting the overall structure.