In 2013–14 they also won their first trophy, the WNL Cup, after defeating Castlebar Celtic 3–0 in the final at Ferrycarrig Park.

[2][3] In 2014–15 Youths won their first Women's National League title after finishing two points clear of second placed UCD Waves.

[7] In the league itself, the two teams finished level on points before Wexford Youths retained the title after a play-off.

[10] In June 2016, Gary Hunt was named as the new senior women's team manager, having been a coach under Will Doyle for the previous two years.

In 2017 Heffernan secured Wexford Youths Women their third WNL title in 4 years, stepping down at the end of the season.

In the season 2021 the team finished 3rd in the league and won the Women's Senior Cup under the leadership Of Stephen Quinn.

Note: Flags indicate national team as defined under FIFA eligibility rules; some limited exceptions apply.

Wexford Youths have been announced as hosts of one of the group stage tournaments with games due to be played at both Ferrycarrig Park and the Waterford Regional Sports Centre.