Setterfield grew up in Albury before taking up a boarding scholarship at Caulfield Grammar School in Melbourne.
Despite being an Essendon supporter as a child, Setterfield nominated the Carlton Football Club as his preferred home.
[7] Widely considered a bargain coup for Carlton, former player and assistant coach Matthew Lappin tweeted "Blues fans, get excited.
[8] Setterfield made his Carlton debut in the Round 1 match against Richmond at the MCG.
[9] Setterfield is cousins with Greater Western Sydney AFLW player Isabel Huntington.