Higgins was appointed High Constable of the Home District in 1826, a position that included being inspector of police for York, Upper Canada at a salary of £40 a year.
[1][2][3] Higgins' term ended in scandal when he was implicated in the death of a man during election day anti-Tory rioting by largely disenfranchised Irish Catholic minority which was put down by a party of Protestant Orangemen, led by Higgins.
Mayor William Lyon Mackenzie, in his role as chief magistrate, held a police court investigation and laid charges against Higgins.
He was exonerated by the grand jury in April 1835 but, by that point city council had already chosen not to reappoint him.
[4][5] He was subsequently appointed High Constable of York County and served for many years.