[8] Critics widely praised the simple and natural controls,[10][12][17][21] and the attractive and well-animated high resolution graphics.

[10][12][17][20][21] GameSpot explained that "Despite its simplicity and the immediate potential for carpal tunnel syndrome, Winter Heat succeeds at providing a fun and varied batch of snowy competitions.

[21][c] Sega Saturn Magazine criticized the bordered display on the PAL conversion, but said the three Saturn-exclusive events are as good or better than the eight events of the arcade version, which in conjunction with the four-player capability gives the game enough longevity to stand up as a console game.

[20] GameSpot and Sega Saturn Magazine both also gave particular praise to the sense of speed in the bobsled event.

EGM gave Winter Heat their "Game of the Month" award, with three of the four members of their review team giving it a 9 out of 10 or better.