[9][10] The week after being named Woman of Steel, Winfield-Hill captained Leeds to victory in the Super League Grand Final.
Five players were shortlisted for the award: Jodie Cunningham, Emily Rudge (both St Helens), Sinead Peach, Rhiannon Marshall (both York City Knights) and Fran Goldthorp (Leeds Rhinos).
[16] Six players were shortlisted for the award: Georgia Roche (Leeds Rhinos), Amy Hardcastle and Jodie Cunningham (both St Helens), Hollie-Mae Dodd, Sinead Peach, and Tara-Jane Stanley, (all three from York City Knights).
The nominees were Keara Bennett (Leeds Rhinos), Jodie Cunningham, Shona Hoyle and Emily Rudge (all St Helens), together with Tara-Jane Stanley and Sinead Peach (both of York Valkyrie).
[27] In September 2024, three players were announced as the nominees for the 2024 award: Faye Gaskin (St Helens), Georgie Hetherington (York Valkyrie) and Lucy Murray (Leeds Rhinos).
[30][31] In June, Hetherington scored on her England début against France and was the player of the match in the Super League Grand Final as York retained the title.
[32][33] Gaskin saw success with St Helens in 2024 as they took the League Leaders' Shield and retained the Challenge Cup, and Murray was named by Leeds Rhinos as the club's women's player of the year.