Awarding the album four stars at CCM Magazine, Matt Conner states, "Worship And Believe definitely feels different than your typical Chapman release, but it’s his voice that keeps this album in familiar territory, even as the pop production and congregational feel bring in fresh elements...it's a welcome shift in career direction for Chapman and hopefully there's more to come.

"[11] Jonathan Andre, indicating in a four and a half star review by 365 Days of Inspiring Media, describes, "Worship and Believe is yet another album full of poignancy and comforting words and Steven continues to present to us reasons why he still carries a mantle of one of CCM’s most prolific and sustainable songwriters of CCM history.

Well done Steven Curtis Chapman for such a wonderful and rewarding album experience, one that will be enjoyed and cherished by myself in months, years and decades to come!

"[1] Signaling in a nine out of ten review from Cross Rhythms, Lins Honeyman writes, "this stunningly inspiring and poignant release.

"[4] Lauren McLean, allotting the album a four and a half star rating from Today's Christian Entertainment, writes, "Worship and Believe is full of beautiful reminders of who we are to the Lord and why we are here.