Like their debut album Sports (2012), You're Gonna Miss It All was written while the band members were attending college.

[13] In June, the group went on a headlining US tour with support from Tiny Moving Parts, the Hotelier and Sorority Noise.

[15] In September, the group played a handful of US shows with I Am the Avalanche and Beach Slang, culminating in an appearance at Riot Fest.

[19] In November and December, the band went on a US tour alongside Knuckle Puck, Crying and Somos with additional support from Walter Mitty and His Makeshift Orchestra, Foxing and Hostage Calm on specific dates.

[31] In 2024, Duke Chronicle said the album "solidified [Modern Baseball's] placement in the canon of indie rock and Midwest emo revival.