It reached number one on the Billboard Mainstream Rock Songs chart in March 2019.
[7][8] A clip of the recording of 'You're the One' went viral on TikTok for Josh Kiszka's dramatic head movements.
Musically, journalist described the song as a "rock ballad" and "more laid back" than much of the band's material released at the time.
[12][13] The drumming was described as similar to the Led Zeppelin song "Your Time is Gonna Come".
[14][11][12] Uproxx praised the song for having a "huge and catchy chorus that is begging to be chanted by a festival crowd" and "a gorgeous song that features a sense of timelessness that few modern rock bands could pull off.