Larry Flick from Billboard described 'You Never Love the Same Way Twice' as "slammin'",[2] and a "disco bauble that tingles with lush strings and a vocal that is commanding without flying out of control.

"[3] He complimented Rozalla's voice as a "warm, soulful quality that brings this disco-drenched house mover to vibrant life."

In his UK chart commentary, James Masterton felt it is "a far more impressive piece of pop dance" than 'This Time I Found Love'.

[5] Tim Jeffery from the Record Mirror Dance Update stated, "Probably her best single since signing to a major", declaring it "a likely hit.

[7] Emma Cochrane from Smash Hits viewed it as "a really upbeat dance track that will make you feel good".