The song has been covered by a number of artists, including Sonia and Sean Maguire, whose versions also charted in the UK.

[9] In 1986, the Decade Remix by DJ Froggy, Simon Harris and KC was released by PRT Records.

[36][37] English actor and singer Sean Maguire covered "You to Me Are Everything" and released it in November 1995 by Parlophone as the second single from his second album, Spirit (1996).

His version was produced by Gary Stevenson, reaching number 16 on the UK Singles Chart,[41] and he performed it on Top of the Pops.

Gill Whyte from Smash Hits gave the cover version three out of five, writing, "Still, this is a top soul number: swoony, '60s groovy party noises, so even with Sean weedying his way through it, it still sounds pretty darn funky.

[43] A Finnish version entitled "Ei enempää voi pyytää" ("He can ask no more") was recorded in 1978 by Petri Pettersson [fi].

Later on, in 1997, songwriter Marina Rei successfully recorded an Italian-language version, "Primavera" ("Spring").