[citation needed] The Steelmen's most notable alumnus was Everett Scott, who played with the club between 1910 and 1913.
[citation needed] The renamed franchise was owned by former Indians coach W. R. Terry and business partner Paul Powers.
[2] In the 1910 season, the Steelmen, under the management of Frank Eustace, placed seventh in the eight-team league, with a record of 55–67.
[citation needed] The Steelmen moved to the Central League in the 1912 season, where it narrowly lost the championship to the Fort Wayne Railroaders.
[citation needed] The Spalding Guide (1913) observed that the Steelmen "gave Fort Wayne a terrific drive for the championship and for much of the season the pennant looked as if it would be won by the Ohio club".