Dan McHugh from Distorted Sound stated that "For a band that have endured considerable adversity to get to this point, …And I Return To Nothingness is one hell of a statement to reassure everyone that Lorna Shore are going absolutely nowhere.

"[8] New Transcendence praised the EP saying, "In 2020, I boldly claimed that Lorna Shore's Immortal stood as one of the finest contributions to deathcore in recent history (possibly ever).

For most, the rockiness of the last two years would have been enough for them to call it a day, but by preserving and fighting against the odds, Lorna Shore have created a new standard for a genre that is becoming increasingly oversaturated by repetitive sound.

From the outright incredible musicianship of all members and the slightly over the top, theatrical approach the band have taken with their evolved sound, I'm confident in saying Lorna Shore will become one of Deathcore’s largest titans.

"[10] Ricky Aarons writing for Wall of Sound reviewed the EP and title track stating: "The band continue with the epic vehicle of destruction, but change tact slightly, in a way that's reminiscent of their previous work...