Unaffiliated candidates Peter Coffin and John Choate also received votes, but their exact totals are unknown.
Many other candidates received votes throughout the county, but their exact totals are unknown: Bliss and Sexton were subsequently elected by the General Court.
Waterman Thomas, Daniel Cony, and Henry Dearborn also received votes, but their exact totals are unknown.
Since no candidate received a majority of votes cast, the General Court elected Dummer Sewall to the seat.
Isaac Winslow, Hugh Orr, Joseph Bryant, James Briggs, and Ebenezer White also received votes.