In its first season of college football, the team compiled a 0–3 record.
In its first season under head coach J. G. Freshour, the team compiled a 5–1 record.
In its second and final season under head coach J. G. Freshour, the team compiled a 0–4 record.
In its first and only season under head coach Matthew Hill, the team compiled a 7–0–1 record and shut out six of eight opponents.
In its first and only season under head coach George Binlein, the team compiled a 4–3 record.