After opening with two matches against amateur clubs, the Continentals took on two ivy league teams that were routinely vying for the intercollegiate championship.

After a respectable loss to Dartmouth, who would end as the runners-up for the eastern championship, Hamilton travelled to Princeton for their first road game of the year.

[3] The final game of the season came in early March and soft ice prevented the team from using the their home rink effectively.

Williams, who was much more used to playing on poor ice, had an easier time navigating up and down the rank and managed to limit the Continentals' chances.

The only goal from the home team came when the visiting netminder was serving one of his two penalties for dropping to the ice and covering the puck but it was not enough for Hamilton to stave off defeat and end the year with a losing record.