The 1923 Buffalo All-Americans season was their fourth in the league and final season as the All-Americans.
The team matched their previous output of 5–4–1, going 5–4–3.
[1] They finished eighth in the league.
The season saw the All-Americans moving to a new home venue, leaving the Villa at Canisius University in favor of Buffalo Baseball Park,[2] a newly upgraded facility with a covered grandstand.