Selectors for the 1926 season included the Green Bay Press-Gazette poll, the Chicago Tribune, and Collyer's Eye.
They are: GB = A poll conducted by the Green Bay Press-Gazette identified first and second teams.
[4] CE = Selected by E.G. Brands, a correspondent for Collyer's Eye, a sports journal published in Chicago.
[1] Players selected by multiple selectors as first-team All-Pros are displayed in bold typeface.
Players who have been inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame are designated with a "†" next to their names.