The National League hit four home runs, tying an All-Star Game record.

[1] Players in italics have since been inducted into the National Baseball Hall of Fame.

Against starting pitcher Whitey Ford, Mays led off the game with a single, then homered in the third.

Eddie Mathews and Stan Musial also hit home runs in the game.

[1] Umpires: Nestor Chylak, Home Plate (AL); Dusty Boggess, First Base (NL); Jim Honochick, Second Base (AL); Tom Gorman, Third Base (NL); Johnny Stevens, Left Field (AL); Vinnie Smith, Right Field (NL)