Led by 14th-year head coach Jeff Voris, Bulldogs compiled an overall record of 3–9 with a mark of 2–6 in conference play, placing eighth in the PFL.

Butler played home games at the Bud and Jackie Sellick Bowl in Indianapolis.

The Pioneer League released their preseason coaches' poll on July 30, 2019.

[1] The Bulldogs had five different players selected to the preseason all–PFL teams.

This college football 2010s season article is a stub.