Finishing with a record of 1–9, the worst record in the league, the team did not win the rights to the first overall pick in the 2023 USFL draft, after the league decided that the winner of the Week 10 game between the 1–8 Maulers and 1–8 Michigan Panthers, would win the first overall pick.
[1] Running backs (RB) Wide receivers (WR) Tight ends (TE) Defensive linemen (DL) Defensive backs (DB) Special teams Reserve Front office Head coaches Offensive coaches
On the first play of the ensuing drive, Josh Love threw an interception to Ahmad Dixon, putting the Stars at the Maulers 21.
The fourth quarter saw the Stars drive 61 yards for a touchdown, and convert the first 3-point attempt in the USFL to put the Maulers down 23–30, which would be the final score.
The Maulers missed 3 field goals and turned the ball over on downs twice before the Panthers scored a fourth quarter touchdown on a 4-yard Reggie Corbin rush.
On their opening drive, the Gamblers took a 7–0 lead following a 24-yard touchdown pass from Clayton Thorson to Isaiah Zuber for the only points of the first quarter.
The Maulers responded in the second quarter with two field goals by Ramiz Ahmed to make the score 10–6 at half.
Lee and Gaither would connect again with no time left on the clock to secure the Maulers' first win, by the final score of 21–20.
Neither team would score again in the first half until the Breakers' Taylor Bertolet added a field goal to close the second quarter, making it 10–0 at halftime.
The Breakers responded with a Jordan Ellis rushing TD to enter the fourth quarter ahead 17–3.
The Maulers would take the lead before the end of the quarter after a Madre London rushing TD to make the score 7–3.
In the second quarter, the teams traded field goals, with the Maulers extending their lead to 10-3 and the Stallions then pulling back within 4 to make the score 10–6 at half.
The Stallions added one final field goal at the two-minute warning to give the Maulers their second straight 26–16 defeat.
The Maulers played their first rematch of the season as they faced division rival New Jersey in their eighth game.
New Jersey scored 16 unanswered points in the second quarter on two touchdowns and a field goal to make it 23–7 at half.
In the second quarter, the lone points were scored when Ramiz Ahmed threw a touchdown on a Maulers fake field goal to give his team the lead.
In the fourth quarter, the Maulers again took the lead on a passing TD, this time from Vad Lee to Tre Walker.
The final, and ultimately decisive points of the game were scored by the Stars on a 51-yard run to secure a 17–16 win.
Ultimately, the Panthers held onto their early lead to prevail by the score of 33–21, securing the first pick in the 2023 USFL draft and dropping the Maulers to last place in the final league standings.