Note: Flags indicate national team as defined under FIFA eligibility rules; some limited exceptions apply.

In preparation for the start of league play, the Birmingham Legion played in a preseason match against Chattanooga FC, a team in the third division league MLS Next Pro, away.

On December 18, 2023, the USL Championship released the regular season schedule for all 24 teams.

As a member of the USL Championship, the Birmingham Legion were matched up against the Chattanooga Red Wolves SC, a fellow team governed by the United Soccer League in the third division USL League One, at home.

[5] After winning in added extra time 4-2 after forward Stefano Pinho scored four goals,[6] the Legion were matched up against fellow USL Championship club Tampa Bay Rowdies away,[7][8] where they would come back and force added extra time after being down by four goals in regular time, before eventually losing 6-4.