[1] The club won their first ever U.S. Open Cup match on April 5, 2023, away to Central Valley Fuego FC.

[4] The club would once again host MLS competition in the US Open Cup, but this time they fell in a penalty-shootout against Los Angeles FC.

[5] The match against LAFC featured the club's highest ever attendance, just shy of a sellout with 5,808 fans on hand.

Monterey Bay was among the USL Championship sides that entered into the third round of the 2024 U.S. Open Cup.

Last season Monterey Bay entered the second round of the 2023 U.S. Open Cup, where they achieved their first US Open Cup victory, away to USL League One side Central Valley Fuego FC.