The Cleveland and Troy clubs played two and four home games there, respectively, in 1872, when they were struggling economically (both eventually went out of business).

The grounds occupied a city block well south and east of the 1871 fire's origin on DeKoven Street.

[1] The first home game for the Chicago White Stockings in the newly formed National League came on May 10, 1876, with the locals defeating Cincinnati.

The final home run at the grounds was hit four days earlier by Lip Pike of Cincinnati.

[Chicago Tribune, April 26, 1874, p. 5] By 1875, the disputes had been resolved and the owners announced plans to develop the mostly-vacant area into residential properties.