It is her first holiday album and features vocals from her friends and family members.

"[2] The album includes a comedy skit featuring Thomas's Sheila Saputo character.

[4] PopMatters gave the album a 6/10 rating, with Ben Child calling it "a pleasant batch of jazz-pop Christmas songs".

[5] The Capital Times described the album as "cute", with Rob Thomas stating "She has a quirky but affecting voice, a wry sense of humor and a deep, questioning Christian faith, and brings them all to bear on this winsome collection.

"[3] The Tucson Weekly gave it a positive review, with Stephen Seigel viewing Thomas's original songs as the highlights.