He played at the defensive tackle position in college and converted to offensive guard as a professional player.

Replogle played college football as a defensive tackle for the Indiana Hoosiers.

[4] In 2017, the Indianapolis Star named him one of the 25 best football players of the previous 25 years for Indiana University.

[5] Repologle was signed as an undrafted free agent by the Atlanta Falcons in April 2013.

[6] He was cut by the Falcons during training camp but eventually signed on as a member of the practice squad in September 2014.