[3] Rolling Stone editors Jon Freeman and Joseph Hudak selected the title track of Cast Iron Pansexual as a "pick of the week" after the album's release, stating that the song "stakes out their place as a born Southerner armed with a radical outlook and a brain that won't just ease up".

Steve Wildsmith of The Daily Times wrote that the album had a "rich currency of exploration, past-life condemnation and present-day illumination.

In 2023, Adeem the Artist was nominated for Emerging Act of the Year at the Americana Music Honors & Awards.

[14] Adeem the Artist released a new single titled "One Night Stand" from their next Thirty Tigers album Anniversary.

[1] Adeem told The Daily Times in 2021 that some of the themes of Cast Iron Pansexual deal with their own gender and sexual identity issues, particularly since they grew up in a Christian household in the Southern United States.